How to improve on Quinian bootstrapping - a response to nativist objections
نویسنده
چکیده
Quinian bootstrapping is Susan Carey's solution to Fodor’s paradox of concept learning. Carey claims that contrary to Fodor’s view, not all learning amounts to hypothesis testing, and that there are ways in which even primitive concepts can be learned. Recently Georges Rey has argued that Carey’s attempt to refute radical concept nativism is unsuccessful. First it cannot explain how the expressive power of mental representational systems could increase due to learning. Second, both Fodorian circularity charges and Goodmanian problems of indeterminacy apply to Carey’s examples of Quinian bootstrapping. I argue that Carey’s examples of bootstrapping can be amended to escape Fodorian and Goodmanian objections. I suggest some ways to improve on our models of concept learning to this end. I also argue that skill learning is the way for mental representational systems to increase their own expressive power, that is, to enrich their conceptual repertoire beyond what compositionality alone affords.
منابع مشابه
The Origin of Concepts
What allows humans to ponder the causes and cure of global warming or of pancreatic cancer? As a matter of logic, a theory of concept acquisition must specify the innate representational primitives that are the input to learning, must describe how representational capacities change with development, and must characterize learning mechanisms that underlie these changes. I will defend three these...
متن کاملThe Language Environment and Syntactic Word-Class Acquisition
Syntactic categories of words in the lexicon are the building blocks from which any type of grammar must be built, and knowledge of these building blocks is an essential part of human language processing. An important research question in Cognitive Science is the question about the nature and origins of this knowledge. So far, a mostly nativist stance on this issue has been taken. The categorie...
متن کاملMindreading, Privileged Access and Understanding Narratives
In this paper we first offer a task analysis of the false belief test including the bidirectional relationship between mindreading and language. Following this we present our theory concerning Quinian bootstrapping of the meaning of mental state terms and relate it to the task-analytic framework. Finally we present an experiment on ascribing privileged access through minimal narratives which is...
متن کاملCan statistical learning bootstrap the integers?
This paper examines Piantadosi, Tenenbaum, and Goodman's (2012) model for how children learn the relation between number words ("one" through "ten") and cardinalities (sizes of sets with one through ten elements). This model shows how statistical learning can induce this relation, reorganizing its procedures as it does so in roughly the way children do. We question, however, Piantadosi et al.'s...
متن کاملConcept Innateness, Concept Continuity, and Bootstrapping.
The commentators raised issues relevant to all three important theses of The Origin of Concepts (TOOC). Some questioned the very existence of innate representational primitives, and others questioned my claims about their richness and whether they should be thought of as concepts. Some questioned the existence of conceptual discontinuity in the course of knowledge acquisition and others argued ...
متن کامل